i UNIVERSITY OF CAPE COAST INNOVATIONS IN BƆBƆƆBƆ OF THE EƲE OF GHANA EYRAM ERIC KWASI FIAGBEDZI 2019 © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library ii ©Eyram Eric Kwasi Fiagbedzi University of Cape Coast © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library iii UNIVERSITY OF CAPE COAST INNOVATIONS IN BƆBƆƆBƆ OF THE EƲE OF GHANA BY EYRAM ERIC KWASI FIAGBEDZI Thesis submitted to the Department of Music and Dance of the Faculty of Arts, College of Humanities and Legal Studies, University of Cape Coast, in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of Doctor of Philosophy Degree in Ethnomusicology JULY 2019 © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library ii DECLARATION Candidate’s Declaration I hear by declare that this thesis is the result of my own original research and that no part of it has been presented for another degree in this university or elsewhere. Candidate’s Signature……………………….............Date…………………… Name: Eyram Eric Kwasi Fiagbedzi Supervisors’ Declaration We hereby declare that the preparation and presentation of the thesis were supervised in accordance with the guidelines on supervision of thesis laid down by the University of Cape Coast. Principal Supervisor’s Signature…………………………Date……………… Name: Prof. Florian Carl Co- Supervisor’s Signature………………………………Date………………... Name: Prof. John Edmund Collins © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library iii ABSTRACT In the 1950s, Bɔbɔɔbɔ, a pan-ethnic dance-music genre emerged in Ghana and performed predominantly among the northern Eʋe in Ghana. Its development has been characterized by socio-political and religious nuances that influenced its stylistic essence. Over the years, cultural transformations and individuals acting as agents of change continue to influence the performance tradition of Bɔbɔɔbɔ thereby making it one of the most popular indigenous dance-music genres in the country. This study examines innovations in Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances since its emergence by focusing on ensembles drawn from across the Volta and Greater Accra regions of Ghana, as well as three famous exponents of the tradition. It offers insight into the practices as characterised in the general transformation that reflects the performance tradition today. The study also examines the socio-cultural and religious significance of themes and drum text of Bɔbɔɔbɔ thus providing a context to explore key factors that continue to enhance and or threaten its sustenance. It adopts qualitative mode of enquiry that embraces ethnographic fieldwork to examine the socio- historical, political, religious and cultural dimensions of Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances. It also explores the use of Bɔbɔɔbɔ song texts as a medium and repository for cultural knowledge and history of the people. The research is framed within the theoritical lenses of social “reconstructionism”, interpretative innovation and the “five-domain framework” for music sustainability. It concludes that within the current socio-cultural environment, the dance-music tradition continues to experience innovations as performance dynamics are reframed to suit contemporary essence. The study contributes to literature in ethnomusicology within the context of innovation and sustainability of Bɔbɔɔbɔ performance. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I wish to express my gratitude to my teachers and supervisors for the individual and significant contributions each has made in shaping my intellectual development: to the late Prof. Willie O. Anku, the late Dr. Nissio Fiagbedzi, and Mrs. Bertha Adom, who were amongst the first people to arouse and sustain my interest in music research. My gratitude extends to Dr. Eric Debrah Otchere for encouraging me when things got tough along the way. I should like particularly to thank Prof. Florian Carl for his general supervision as principal Supervisor, for his editorial comments and advice, and the general encouragements he gave me which helped me in completing this study. To Professor John Collins: I am particularly grateful for your criticism and valuable suggestions and encouragement as my second supervisor. My study at the University of Cape Coast would not have been successful without the financial support I received working as Local Project Coordinator for the DAAD SDG Graduate School Performing Sustainability: Cultures and Developments in West Africa. I owe special thanks to Prof. Raimund Vogels, Dr. Michael Fuhr, Steering Committee members and fellow coordinators: Nepomuk, Meike, and Chris, and the entire student cohort of SDG Graduate School for their support. To my friends Adowa Arhine, Kwashie Kuwor, Derrick Degboe, Senyo Adzei and Eric Sunu Doe, thank you for being there for me. To my family members and in-laws: your show of love was excellent! I also wish to thank Gideon for assisting with the music transcriptions and Osman for formatting the work. To the members of the ensembles and all the people interviewed, I owe you sincere thanks. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library v DEDICATION To my dear wife, Irene, and children, Melike, Selikem and Setutsi © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library vi TABLE OF CONTENTS Page DECLARATION ii ABSTRACT iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS iv DEDICATION v TABLE OF CONTENTS vi LIST OF FIGURES x LIST OF ACRONYMS xii CHAPTER ONE:INTRODUCTION Background to the Study 1 Problem Statement 6 Objectives of the Study 9 Research Questions 9 Significance of the Study 10 Literature Review 10 The Concept of Innovation 15 Theoretical Framework 16 The Interpretative Innovation Theory 17 The Theoretical Model of Social Reconstructionism 19 The Stage of Social Deconstruction 22 Methodology 25 Interviews 27 Audio and Visual Materials 28 Digital Archives 29 Data Processing and Analysis 29 © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library vii Scope of Study 30 Organisation of the Study 38 CHAPTER TWO: POLITICAL AND SOCIO-CULTURAL HISTORY OF THE EƲE OF GHANA Introduction 40 Origins and Migrations 40 Natural Resources and Economic Activities 47 Religious Practices 50 Language 54 Eʋe Music 55 Expressions for Eʋe music and dance performances 56 Classification of Eʋe music 58 Instrumental Resources 60 Chapter Summary 67 CHAPTER THREE: HISTORICAL EXPLORATION OF THE ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF BƆBƆƆBƆ IN GHANA Introduction 69 Precursors of Bɔbɔɔbɔ 69 Konkoma Marching Bands 70 Tuidzi Dance Music 75 Akpese Dance Music 78 Origin of Bɔbɔɔbɔ 83 Bɔbɔɔbɔ in the Church/Christianisation of Bɔbɔɔbɔ 97 Bɔbɔɔbɔ brass bands 106 Chapter Summary 108 © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library viii CHAPTER FOUR: PERFORMANCE PRACTICE OF BƆBƆƆBƆ ENSEMBLES Introduction 111 Organisation and functions of Bɔbɔɔbɔ ensembles 112 Rehearsal and Performance Spaces Organisation 122 Performance 122 Instrumentation 124 Dances incorporated into present day Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances 128 Presentation of Songs 130 Costume 132 Use of alcohol or liquor 135 Bɔbɔɔbɔ competitions 137 Some famous exponents of Bɔbɔɔbɔ music 140 Chapter Summary 158 CHAPTER FIVE: THE SOCIO-CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE OF BƆBƆƆBƆ MUSIC TEXTS Introduction 161 Music Texts 161 Analysis of selected Bɔbɔɔbɔ songs texts 162 Drum texts 211 Chapter Summary 217 CHAPTER SIX: THE SUSTAINABILITY OF BƆBƆƆBƆ Introduction 219 Systems of Learning Music 219 Drumming, Singing and Dancing 224 © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library ix Musicians and Communities 227 Regulations and Infrastructure 232 Contexts and Constructs 233 Media and Music Industry 239 Chapter Summary 243 CHAPTER SEVEN: SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Introduction 246 Summary 246 Findings 248 Conclusions 253 Recommendation 256 Suggestions for Further Research 256 BIBLIOGRAPHY 258 APPENDICES 276 APPENDIX A: LIST OF PEOPLE INTERVIEWED AND GROUPS 277 APPENDIX C: IMAGES OF BƆBƆƆBƆ PERFORMANCE STYLES 282 APPENDIX D: MUSICAL TRANSCRIPTION OF SELECTED BƆBƆƆBƆ SONGS 289 APPENDIX E:RHYTHMS OF SELECTED BƆBƆƆBƆ INSTRUMENTS 305 APPENDIX F:TEXTUAL TRANSCRIPTION OF SELECTED BƆBƆƆBƆ SONGS 307 APPENDIX G: ƲUGBE: AGBELIDZEDZE 312 © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library x LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page 1 Social Reconstrctionism Model 20 2 Map showing the historical migration of the Eʋe 41 3 Gankogui 63 4 Toke 63 5 Akoge 64 6 Adodo 64 7 Axatse (Enmeshed Rattle) 65 8 Akaye (Container Rattle) 65 9 Kitikpo 66 10 Performance set-up of Nuatro’s band 90 11 Nuatro’s Bɔbɔɔbɔ group with Nuatro (from bottom left) holding a stick and a hat 90 12 Poster of OMSU 2000-year group advertising their Bɔbɔɔbɔ event 117 13 A four-set Bɔbɔɔbɔ drum 126 14 Members of Nutifafa Bɔbɔɔbɔ group playing the seven-set drums during a funeral thanksgiving at Dzolo-Kpuita in the Volta region 126 15 Dondo or hourglass drum 127 16 Nutifafa Borborbor Group from Kpando in performance 130 17 Bɔbɔɔbɔ dancers in Eʋe traditional costume flaunting white handkerchiefs 133 18 Dancers of Edzordzinam Fafali Borborbor Group wearing a pair of socks during a performance at a wedding reception 133 © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library xi 19 Dancers and percussionists of Fafali Edzordzinam Borborbor Group in different costumes during a wedding reception 134 20 Image of Bɔbɔɔbɔ bitters 137 21 Poster of Bɔbɔɔbɔ competition 139 22 CD cover bearing the image of Efo Senyo 149 23 CD cover bearing the image of Israel Maweta 151 24 CD cover bearing the image of Wofa Atta 155 25 A poster of Gbi Festival with Bɔbɔɔbɔ listed as part of the festival activities 239 26 Samples of fliers advertising special programs for Bɔbɔɔbɔ as side attraction 239 © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library xii LIST OF ACRONYMS ARS Apostles Revelation Society CNC Center for National Culture CPP Convention Peoples Party CYB Christian Youth Builders CYO Christian Youth Organisation E.P. Evangelical Presbyterian EPL English Premier League EPSU Evangelical Presbyterian Students Union GBC Ghana Broadcasting Cooperation GTP Ghana Textile Print ICAMD Center for African Music and Dance NDC National Democratic Congress NPP New Patriotic Party OMSU Old Mawuli Students Union PNDC Provisional National Defence Council PNP Peoples National Party TVT Trans- Volta Togoland UCC University of Cape Coast UN United Nations © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 1 CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION Background to the Study Cultural forms in Africa are seen as a significant part of people’s lives. In the process of ensuring continuity in the safeguarding and preservation of these unique traditional cultures within time and space, transformations are bound to occur. These may be as a result of human migration, adaptation, and cultural change, among other reason. Such observations have been acknowledged by scholars such as Avorgbedor (2001), Barnett (1953), Gbolonyo (2009) and Nketia (1974). This thesis traces the transformations and innovations in Bɔbɔɔbɔ, a recreational music and dance culture of the Eʋe people in Ghana, with reference to the people and language. In this thesis, the group of people whose music tradition is being investigated is referred to as the Eʋe/s. Kuada and Chacha in their historical account of the Eʋe at the tail end of the 20th Century, identified settlement of the Eʋe in Ghana as ‘the area south- east of the Volta Lake’ (Kuada & Chacha, 1999). The term ‘Northern-Eʋe’ signifies the Eʋe-speaking people that are found north of the Southern Eʋes (Agbodeka, 1997) in Ghana. Here, there are two groups, based on their language and origin. One group is made up of the majority of the people who are generally referred to by the other Eʋe-speaking people as Ʋedometɔwo. These Ʋedometɔwo are part of the three main groups of Eʋe that migrated from Notsie during the reign of Togbe Agorkorli I in the 17th Century (Amenumey, 1999; 1986). The second group in Ghana, the Northern Eʋes, claim different origins but speak shades of Guan and Akan dialects as their first language, and Eʋe as a second language. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 2 Collectively, all these Northern Eʋe groups share similar socio-political and economic experiences. The occupations of the people include crop farming, animal farming and hunting. Crops that are farmed include cereals (sorghum, rice and maize), legumes (Bambara groundnut, kersting’s groundnut, melegueta pepper, cowpea), tubers (yam, cocoyam, cassava) and tree crops (oil palm, akee apple, shea butter tree and Kola species). Other crops include banana and plantains. They also cultivate cash crops such as coffee and cocoa for export. With regard to animal farming, people keep poultry, pigs, goats and sheep for local consumption and sometimes for commercial purposes. Hunting of mammals, rodents and birds with guns and traps, is done by boys and men. Fishing is another occupation that is popular and lucrative along the rivers and the Volta Lake. Apart from agriculture-related activities, the Northern Eʋes also undertake indigenous economic activities such as basketry, palm-wine tapping, smithing, wood working, pottery and weaving of traditional cloth known as Eʋe- kete (Eʋe-kente) in Agotime area. In terms of religion, traditionally all Northern Eʋes believe in Mawuga (a Supreme Being), but there are others who also believe in various spirits, including ancestral spirits. The introduction of Christianity among the Northern Eʋe communities by the North German Mission Society (Norddeutsche Mission, Bremen, now the Evangelical Presbyterian Church) in early 19th century (Gavua, 2000), has resulted in majority of the people subscribing to the Christian faith. Major Christian churches include the Evangelical Presbyterian Church and the Roman Catholic Church. A small portion (about 5.7%) of the population in the Volta region also subscribe to the Islamic faith (Ghana © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 3 Staistical Service, May 2012), leading to the creation of places for Muslim worship and Islamic schools within the area. Bɔbɔɔbɔ (pronounced ) as a dance music tradition is an intercultural genre of the Eʋes of Ghana which gained popularity in the 1950s as a secular pro-youth recreational music and dance type. It combines folk songs, drumming practices and dance movements with borrowed characteristics from Western regimental music. It later spread country-wide through Eʋe labour migrants living in major towns and cities in Ghana. Bɔbɔɔbɔ performance has over the decades gone through transformations and has become quite sophisticated in contemporary times, making it arguably the most popular indigenous dance music genre in contemporary Ghana. It has also become a pan- Eʋe and pan-ethnic genre. This feat may be attributed to the innovations in the performance of the genre since its inception. In keeping tradition within the Eʋe culture, the emphasis has always been on ensuring a certain level of authenticity succinctly demonstrated in the following Eʋe proverb: Ka xoxo ŋue wogbea yeyea do (An old rope is a model for the new one). The context within which this age-long Eʋe proverb was birthed is the unpleasant experiences and hardships the Eʋe people suffered under the rule of King Agokorli in Nortsie. Oral history has it that when he asked them to use their hands to weave a rope or thread out of wet clay, Amega Wenya, one of the leaders of the Eʋes, requested the king to make a sample for them to see in order to serve as a model based on which they would be able to accomplish the task he had set for them. This event is captured in the lyrics of this Eʋe agbadza (misego) song: © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 4 Ooo ne nyeanyi woagbi ka Eee ne nyeanyi woagbi kaa. ‘Gokorlia ntɔ nenyeanyi woagbi kaa. Torgbui Wenya kplɔviawo dzo lo English translation Ooo he should weave rope out of the clay Yes, he should weave rope out of the clay Agorkoli himself should weave rope out of the clay Torgbui Wenya has taken his children away Although the context within which the proverb was birthed was that of cruelty, oppression and despotism, it could be conceived in a broader sense as the adaptation of old practices and conventions which are necessary conditions for the expression of both new and personal concepts, values or insights. Almost on a regular basis, our societies in Ghana continue to experience transformations (changes and developments) in many aspects of our daily lives, including the performance of our music and dance forms. How these innovations occur, and the mechanisms and agents which serve as catalysts to them, remain questions begging for answers. However, an intense reflection will perhaps provide human creativity as the major and most important response to these questions. In all the activities we undertake, be they cultural, social, political or religious, innovation and creativity form the core aspect. This study on innovation is a result of my personal interest in the performance of Bɔbɔɔbɔ. It is a recreational music of the Eʋe people which emerged as a cross-cultural recreational dance music genre started by the youth in the late 1940s and became very popular in the 1950s. It is currently still associated with both young people and adults. Over the years, social, political © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 5 and religious factors have led to the genre going through dynamic processes of change as result of reinterpretations and innovations by musicians and performing groups. Bɔbɔɔbɔ is one of the indigenous dance music traditions that has spread country-wide, particularly in communities with a sizeable Eʋe population. Moreover, Christian churches such as the Evangelical Presbyterian Church (former Bremen Mission), and the Apostles Revelation Society, (all Eʋe- dominated churches), have incorporated Bɔbɔɔbɔ into their liturgy since the 1980s. This dance-music has therefore found new locations in contemporary times, making it, in my view, the most widespread indigenous dance music genre in Ghana today. Although originally created among the Northern Eʋes, it has also currently become a pan-Eʋe genre. This development may be attributed to the innovations in the performance of the genre since its inception. Indeed, much has been done in terms of research on Eʋe music, so much so that Green (2012) observes that among all the ethnic groupings in Africa, the music of the Eʋe of Ghana has caught the attention of most research scholars, hence the assertion that it provided the foundation on which the field of ethnomusicology was fashioned. But more specifically, Otchere (2016) notes without a doubt, that the Music of the Anlo-Eʋe is included in the most researched and published music traditions in Ghana. Diverse aspects of Anlo Eʋe music for example its dance-drumming traditions (Ladzekpo, 1971; Younge 2011), structural organization of drumming (Anku, 2009; Locke, 1987; Pantaleoni 1972), history (Agbodeka, 1997; Gbolonyo, 2005), singing styles and expressive forms (Agawu, 2016; Avorgbedor, 2001), communal organization and performance practice (Amoaku, 1975; Dor 2004), critique of © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 6 form and structure (Agawu, 2003; Fiagbedzi, 2009) and so on, have much received scholarly attention over the years. Unfortunately, same cannot be said about the music of of northern Eʋe origin. Problem Statement The Volta region is the traditional home for Eʋes and Bɔbɔɔbɔ music. Suburbs of Accra also resonates with a sizeable number of Eʋes living there (Ghana Statistical Service, 2010). Both areas with Eʋe populations are dotted with several performing groups, amongst are Bɔbɔɔbɔ groups which represents cultural significance of the Eʋe. For most Bɔbɔɔbɔ musicians, and for many as socially and politically conscious individuals, Bɔbɔɔbɔ gives them a tool with which to express a sense of self, a philosophy, and an ideology. For most interviEʋees in this research, Bɔbɔɔbɔ music performance communicate and reinforce pride in Eʋe selfhood. According to Xornam Atta Owusu, a Bɔbɔɔbɔ practitioner, "There's a sense of pride when people hear Bɔbɔɔbɔ. They say 'that's our music.' It gives people a sense of pride in their Eʋeness (Personal interview. April 25, 2018). Therefore, Bɔbɔɔbɔ is a pan-ethnic genre. In this context, “ethnicity is an organizing mechanism and music a symbol system, certain elements therein possess the compelling power to draw people together in their struggle for identity and self-determination. "Ethnic symbol systems, or 'ethnicities,'… create collective conscience... Ethnicity is an ideology . . . for pursuing major values deemed not shared by others in the [cultural, social and political] arena" (Aronson, 1976:13-15). Royce (1982) also notes that contemporary ethnicity, "can be a weapon, a tool for improving one's status." Moreover, the use of traditional symbols and representations renders the past important "not for its own sake, but for the sense © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 7 of tradition that it confers on contemporary groups, which may, in turn, be used to gain both material and spiritual advantages" (220- 221). I agree with the views expressed by Aronson and Royce for the reason that, in recent times, it is common to see Eʋes (both performers and enthusiasts) take pride in the performance of Bɔbɔɔbɔ and holding it in very high esteem thereby reinforcing their pride and collective realities as Eʋes. Members of other ethnic groups in Ghana see Bɔbɔɔbɔ as a pan-ethnic and pan-Eʋe genre because it has become synonymous to not only the northern Eʋes among whom it started but the generality of Eʋes in Ghana and Togo who have accepted and integrated it into many aspects of their socio-cultural and religious realities. It also continues to enjoy popularity among non-Eʋes in Ghana. Beyond that, since its inception, Bɔbɔɔbɔ has been performed for the last seven and a half decades. During those periods its performance has navigated political, social-cultural and religious (Christianity) dimensions. Undoubtedly, such political, socio-cultural and religious (Christianity) and presently, technological influences have triggered changes in the performance organisations and use of Bɔbɔɔbɔ by performing groups and institutions respectively. Individually and collectively, practitioners through their creativities and improvisations have incorporated new items which have resulted in transformations and modifications in Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances thereby making it more stylish. Furthermore, Sustainability which is a hard concept to ignore in contemporary times (Titon, 2015), because of the urgent need to ardently maintain and preserve the environment and culture. Cultural sustainability deals with the preservation of the culture of a given group of people such that future © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 8 generations can access cultural resources and meet their cultural needs, and the current generation can access cultural products, participate and enjoy them without inequity (Throsby, 2008). On the other hand, music sustainability according to Grant (2013:1) is the ability of a music genre to endure, without implications of either a static tradition or a preservationist bearing”. To the extent that Bɔbɔɔbɔ has remained vibrant and popular amount the people over the years it will be very interesting to understand the circumstances or strategies that have contributed to Bɔbɔɔbɔ evolution and survival. Although, a number of scholars such as Agawu (1985, 1988, 2016), Avorgbedor (1986), Gbolonyo (2009), Amegago (2011), Younge (2012) and Dor (2012), have written on several aspects of Eʋe music traditions little attention have been paid to the ways musical forms are being modified in contemporary contexts of performance. Scholars such as Lareau (2002), Witty (2009) and Gallo (2015) and have also made researched on aspects of the Bɔbɔɔbɔ music tradition, they all approached their studies from entirely music analysis perspectives. In addition, discourses on music cultures sometimes create the impression that performances have always been there and will continue to exist for future generations, portraying such music traditions as unaltered by the religious, social, economic and political influences that are transforming the lives of the people who perform them and the entire performance. In addition, the issue of innovation in musical forms is very important and needs to be examined because it raises several interesting questions about the nature of culture, the agents and mechanisms of change, and the processes through which innovative elements in the musical forms gain approval and validity among people. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 9 Therefore, this thesis explores Bɔbɔɔbɔ holistically, touching on its music, its dance and its nature as an identity of a people. It is delivered through ethnographic fieldwork where interrogation of its process of change and innovation is done and its sustainability in both rural and the urban communities, all of which is documented as a contribution to scholarship in ethnomusicology. In spite of the fact that scholars have researched extensively the music and dance traditions of the Eʋe and Eʋe dance drumming, with a few mentioning some aspects of Bɔbɔɔbɔ, more could be said about the innovations this dance music tradition has brought to the Ghanaian music landscape since its emergence. In the light of the above, the goal of this study is to contribute to research on music of the Eʋe in Ghana by investigating how Bɔbɔɔbɔ ensembles have maintained performance conventions and introduced new ones over the years Objectives of the Study The study i. Explores the history and development of Bɔbɔɔbɔ dance music; ii. Examines the innovations in Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances in both Christian and non-Christian contexts; iii. Explores the themes around which Bɔbɔɔbɔ song texts revolve and their significance to the people, and iv. Examines sustainability of Bɔbɔɔbɔ performance. Research Questions Questions that will guide my study are as follows: • What are the precursors of Bɔbɔɔbɔ? • What are the innovations that occured in course of its development? © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 10 • How do Bɔbɔɔbɔ musicians create their songs, drum rhythms and dance movements? • How have Bɔbɔɔbɔ artists contributed to the innovations and promotion of the genre? • Which themes are Bɔbɔɔbɔ songs texts founded on? • How have Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances been sustained? Significance of the Study The study offers insight into Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances through the lenses of innovative practices that have contributed to the transformation in general and the sophistication being experienced and reflected in this genre presently. It details the themes of Bɔbɔɔbɔ song and drum texts and provides reflections on their significance in the socio-cultural and religious lives of the people. The study also explores the key factors that have sustained the dance music form over the years, highlighting the potential threats to the sustainable future of Bɔbɔɔbɔ. Finally, it contributes to the growing scholarship in ethnomusicology in general and Eʋe music traditions in particular. Literature Review Prior to my fieldwork, I searched for written scholarship at libraries and for audio-visual materials. I made visits to the International Center for African Music and Dance (ICAMD), the J.H. Kwabena Nketia Audio-visual Archive, the digital audio library of Ghana Broadcasting Cooperation (GBC) and the Volta Star Radio, a GBC regional FM station the Ho in the Volta region of Ghana. The aim for exploring the Audio-visual archives was to assess the number of old original Bɔbɔɔbɔ recordings to ascertain which groups performed © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 11 where and when it was done. It also afforded me the opportunity to listen to old Bɔbɔɔbɔ recordings and to watch recorded performances in order to structure germane questions for field investigation. This experience also formed my initial basis to conceptualise creativity and innovations in Bɔbɔɔbɔ performance. At the J. H. Kwabena Nketia Audio-visual archive housed at the Institute of African Studies, University of Ghana, I found two related materials. One was a field recording that was done on 3rd December 1972, which featured the Accra New Town Nɔvisi Akpese Group. This recording, labelled AWG-E-42a, has seven songs in track 1 and six songs in track 2, all performed in a medley. The second audio recording which was done on 22nd November 1971 at Have Etoe, was labelled AWG-E-37. It has a total of eighteen songs performed in medley. At the GBC, however, I was quite disappointed because although I had the opportunity to listen to some old recordings, there was no information on them. One could not tell the name of the group, the genre, where and when the recordings were done. The case was somewhat different at their regional FM station, in that although there appear to be no written records on the music files, the resource person was able to give me the names of the performing groups and where they were located. From these field recordings in the archives I gained a sense of how it was performed in the past and the nature of rhythmic accompaniments and songs that went with the performances. Inquiry was made into both published and unpublished research works on general themes such as creativity, innovation, history, ethnography and geography of the Eʋe covered in my study. I found four related research works within the last two decades. These include Lareau’s (2002) unpublished M.Phil. theses, entitled The Borborbor of the Northern Eʋe: Functional and Technical © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 12 Aspects; Witty’s (2005) procedure of northern Eʋe borborbor master drumming: A case study of the Dzogbefeme-Avatime Borborbor group; Younge’s (2011) Music and Dance Traditions of Ghana and Gallo’s (2015) MA thesis, Norvinyo Borborbor: A Study of Eʋedome Dance-Drumming from Kpando, Ghana. Lareau (2002) investigates the functionality of Bɔbɔɔbɔ and discusses how the melodies and rhythms have been influenced by western melodies such as hymns. He analyses Bɔbɔɔbɔ songs using Western analytical tools (form, pitch, scale) and Nketia’s method of analysing African song form which are call and response, solo and chorused refrain, mixed sectional form and declamation. He noted that most of the western melodies came directly from the Christian denominational churches that were established by the Bremen and Basel missions. Witty (2005) discusses the series of steps and techniques in Bɔbɔɔbɔ master drumming in Dzogbefeme-Avatime Borborbor ensemble. He employs Structural Set Theory (see Anku, 1992) to understand the procedures used by the master drummers in the ensemble. He summarises and analyses the variable rhythms of the master drums in relation to the bell pattern. He demonstrates how the master drummers creatively shift their rhythmic motifs to conform with the rhythmic motifs of the supporting drums and the bells. Although the work examines how the master drummer reorganises the rhythmic patterns available for borborbor performances in the ensemble, it fails to mention the new ideas the drummer may have incorporated into the performance. Witty’s approach is more technical. Besides, it lacks discussion on the aspects of innovation. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 13 Younge (2011) provides basic information about the socio-historical backgrounds of selected ethnic groups in Ghana and their music and dance traditions, in which Bɔbɔɔbɔ is featured. He provides pictures and illustrations of the instrumental resources and demonstrations of how they are manipulated. The work also provides activities which serve as guidelines to educators on how to provide instruction on Bɔbɔɔbɔ dance-drumming. Gallo (2015) in his MA thesis redresses the corpus of research devoted to Eʋe musics in a ternary metric framework. He examines the technical and compositional aspects of Bɔbɔɔbɔ music, using a blend of the Burns’ Archetypes and Locke’s Principles of the theory of Quaternary Rhythm, and suggests that it is possible for the melodic and rhythmic materials of Bɔbɔɔbɔ to be theoretically rendered in a quaternary metric framework. Fiagbedzi (1997) presents a comprehensive overview of the musical tradition of the Anlo Eʋe, focusing on historical development, social, political and religious aspects in terms of usage. He explains how the musical tradition has been influenced as a result of cultural contacts, and further discusses the musical styles, the meanings and their importance in the everyday lives of the people. Based on song texts, historical dates, and general musical practice, the study provides a classification of musical types as reconstruction of the historical development of Eʋe music. Avorgbedor (2001) investigates halo ‘songs of insult’ as literary creation and how they mediate and neutralise violence in the community. In this work, he engages in a thorough analysis of halo, indicating the wide range of literary devices Eʋe composers employ in their songs. The work shows how powerful and relevant song texts are in the social and political lives of the Eʋe. The © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 14 conception, description and explanation it provides about the poetic artistry of the Eʋe composers and the degree to which they engage songs and song texts in information dissemination make them germane to my research, especially the chapter on themes of Bɔbɔɔbɔ song texts. Dor (2004) discusses how music compositions are realised through collaborative efforts of singers, dancers, drummers and others among the Anlo Eʋe. He provides the processes through which creativity and innovations are employed both at the individual and communal levels. He further observes the havolu session as providing an avenue for creating and concretising songs in Anlo Eʋe genres, and acknowledges the place of individuality as the interpretative framework for emphasising collective creativity in Eʋe cultural community. He also employed African philosophical thoughts to support the importance of communal co-existence and personhood. Avorgbedor’s (1986) research on Modes of musical continuity among the Anlo Eʋe of Accra, focuses on the ‘symbiotic’ relationship between music and society, as revealed in the Anlo voluntary associations in urban Accra, and explains the influences of secular familiarisation on the various forms in which music is performed and organised. He also discusses the framework within which musical innovation is defined among the Anlo living in urban Accra. The relevance of this study to my work lies in the focus on voluntary associations, performing groups and their parameters for determining musical innovation within their context. Although Avorgbedor’s work focuses on musical innovation to the detriment of the non-musical, my study encompasses innovations in all aspects of Bɔbɔɔbɔ. In addition, the methodological approach of the work also provided helpful insights for my study. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 15 These works were very helpful as they provided information on what aspects of Bɔbɔɔbɔ of the Eʋe have been researched. However, as I have indicated earlier, it is apparent that issues of creativity in performances and innovations, which in my opinion are critical in view of the current phenomena in Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances, have not received much attention by most researchers. The musicians and members of Bɔbɔɔbɔ bands travel for performances to and from Eʋe-land and parts of the Greater Accra Region, hence aspects of the research were conducted through ethnographic participant observation. The Concept of Innovation A number of literatures I have examined on the issue of innovation are of the same opinion that “change” is a common occurrence in all societies. To put it differently, human beings by nature have the propensity to create ‘new’ things as result of desire that happens based on different proportions and motivational factors. Navigating through the literature, it was obvious that there seem not to be straightforward assertion of the concept of innovation. Barnett’s (1953) describes innovation as “ an Innovation is here defined as any thought behaviour or thing that is new because it is qualitatively different from existing forms. Strictly speaking every innovation is an idea or a constellation of ideas; but some innovations per their nature remains organisations only whereas others may be given overt and tangible expression” (1953:7) All innovations have antecedents. All are therefore derived from others. In defining an innovation as something that is qualitatively new, emphasis is placed upon re-organisation rather than upon quantitative variations as the criterion of a novelty. Innovation does not result from the addition or subtraction of parts. It takes place only when there is a recombination of them (1953:9). © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 16 This suggests that innovation entails not just the collection or assemblage of ideas, sounds, musical instruments and other, but the reorganisation or recombination of such ideas and items, and transforming them into something that has a quality that is different from prevailing forms. Barnet maintains that innovation does not come out of consciously making attempts to plan it, but rather, they are mostly unintended or accidental with others coming across as both unexpected and unwanted (Barnett, 1959). Perullo (2012) notes that Innovation occurs as artists modify the sounds, uses, and interpretations of music. It is a means of slightly transforming words and sounds in ways that make them appear new within a specific context. Barnett also provides details on a variety of factors that are potentially conducive or disruptive to innovation. Some of which are individualism and competition, deprivation or wants, and sudden catastrophic events. On the importance of sociocultural climate, whiles Rogers (1962) notes that “as individual’s innovativeness varies directly with the norms of the social system on innovation” (1962:71), Barnett (1953) agrees observing that “The conflict between socially approved behaviour of any sort and individual desires has produced a great many innovations. The desire to act in accordance with legal or other socially sanctioned norms and the private urge to ignore or by-pass them have already been a prolific source of cultural change (1953:131). Theoretical Framework In order to fully discuss the innovations in Bɔbɔɔbɔ, I employed the Eʋe concept of aɖaŋu, which is an overarching concept that embodies creativity. Other concepts that would be used are hakpakpa (song composition), ʋugbe © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 17 kpakpa (drum language composition) and astiawɔwɔ or adodede (choreographic style), which are all elements under the concept of aɖaŋu in Eʋe indigenous culture. From an epistemological perspective, aɖaŋu encompasses creative art of all forms. As translated by Westerman (1928; 1973) cited in Fiagbedzi (2005), the verb dze aɖaŋu or wɔ aɖaŋu is ‘to be clever’, able, skilful.’ This implies that aɖaŋu is not only associated with (a) skill or ability, the Eʋe word for which is nutete, but also with (b) cleverness or zaza (i.e in the sense of being mentally quick, resourceful, ingenuous). Aɖaŋudzedze or aɖaŋuwɔwɔ, the noun forms of verbal expressions, would therefore not denote just the attributes and the act or process of using skills acquired for doing something, but also dexterity or adroitness. Aɖaŋu has both practical and theoretical (philosophical) dimensions. For one to gain aɖaŋu requires action and individual efforts. Thus, the practical dimension of Eʋe philosophy is already embedded in the original meaning of the word. According to Gbolonyo (2009), aɖaŋu is a mental faculty that is largely inborn. However, where aɖaŋu means skill, skilfulness or practical knowledge, it still has to be learned and developed. With aɖaŋu, the individual artist or musician assumes a specific character and through a series of negotiations with their environment and community, makes decisions to reconstruct culture (in this case, music). This means that regardless of how one views aɖaŋu, it is a concept that provides the foundations for creative processes artists or musicians utilize to bring about innovation in their performances. The Interpretative Innovation Theory According to Meyer’s (1989) interpretative innovation theory, what should determine innovation is centred on the distinction between devising and © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 18 replication. Any performance of a piece of music in a way that shows an attempt at originality to an earlier one is not a replication of another one. Thus, implying that the composition is the result of a creative work of art. To him, the performers in this grouping are those qualified to be considered as creative artists. Within the constraints of the performance tradition of a musical culture such performers devise “novel realisations (interpretations)” and choose among the possibilities devised. Meyer’s theory posits that, because individual culture nurtures and promotes the development of its own peculiar skills and behaviours, both the environment, in addition to the innate feature, plays a significant part in the individual differences. In other words, it suggests that the creative abilities of an individual are rooted on the nature and background of individual difference or uniqueness. Beeko (2005) asserts that individual difference is a factor that contributes to the creative abilities of individuals who come from the same cultural environment. Considering the fact that each culture intends to strive for and develop a set of standardized aptitudes, aesthetics and personality characteristics; the environment, besides the inborn qualities, is crucial in shaping individual difference. Beeko notes that the environment accelerates an individual’s aptitude to bring change. However how an individual manipulates their creative abilities within the confines of the cultural environment towards its development, is essential to determining why, in the very cultural environment, some individual creators are inclined towards innovation while others, are disposed to elaboration. Individual innovators create new ideas while individual elaborators ‘replicate’ already existing materials (2005:22). © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 19 The interpretative innovation theory suggests that individual creators, in a given cultural context, play a key role to bring progress, innovation and change through their introduction of new creative ideas into the culture. The marked effect of their works on the society makes such creative individuals become role models and agents of cultural change within their own context. Owing to this theory, creators come across as individuals who are discontent and question the status quo in their environment. In terms of music, they use their skills and abilities to transform creative concepts in terms of music performance practices, redefining the uses and roles of music thereby reviving behaviours and practices. With the interpretative innovation theory, this study attempts to investigate how Bɔbɔɔbɔ artists employ their creativity towards innovation within their performances. The Theoretical Model of Social Reconstructionism Also useful to this research is the theoretical model of social reconstructionism which is proposed in Emielu (2013). This theory is employed to analyse the development and sustenance of Bɔbɔɔbɔ in Ghana. Social reconstructionism is a theoretical model that is grounded on the social construction theory. The social reconstructionism model is a three-phase cyclical and progressive model which process starts with the construction stage through the social process, moves on to a stage of deconstruction which then creates or develops a reconstruction process. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 20 Figure 1: Social Reconstrctionism Model Scholars such as Berger and Luckman (1966), Searle (1995), Hacking (1999), and Boghossian (2001) have written and theorized extensively on social construction. It interrogates the manner in which social occurrences and experiences develop in specific social contexts. Social constructionism or ‘social constructivism’, as it is also known, focuses on unearthing the processes by which social phenomena are created, established, and transformed into traditions that are alive in society (Emielu, 2013). Social construction was first theorised by the French social philosopher called Emile Durkheim (1858-1917) in his anthropological writings on collective behaviour. Durkheim was of the strong view that the complicated nature of social forces which determine social actions, interactions and social negotiations contribute to the makeup of individuals in a society. He also argued that the individual should at all times be considered in the society where he lives. As a sociological theory, social constructionism was made popular in America by the publication of Berger and Luckman (1966), in which they posited that when individuals or groups interact in a social system for a period of time, they develop concepts or material representations of each other’s actions. These actions subsequently become recurrent and translate into mutual roles played by the actors in relation to each other. The continual performance of these roles results in mutual interactions that become customary. Social Deconstruction social Reconstructionism Social Construction © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 21 Emielu’s (2013) social reconstructionism model is cyclical and progressive one which comprises the social construction stage, social deconstruction stage and the social reconstruction stage. At the stage of social construction, he notes that there should be some necessary conditions for a musical style to occur. Such conditions include a) The availability of musical resources – existing musical sounds, musical instruments and relevant knowledge and expertise that contribute to musical creativity; b) Obtainability of competent musicians to create the new musical sound; industries that market and promote the music and the target audience or social group the music is made for, and c) A conducive socio-cultural and economic environment which anchors the development of the music under consideration. Features of the social construction stage are: a. The manner in which the available musical resources are combined into a coherent and recognizable musical core which attributes musical essence into the product. The music creator or originator’s ideologies and intentions are also imprinted on the style to give it meaning and musical symbolism. b. Social action, interaction and mediation between social groups such as artistes, listeners, producers, marketers, promoters and other social groups who are indirectly involved in the musical stream will add new meanings that may go beyond what was intended by the creators. Through this social process, the nature and content of the music is shaped. c. The musical style has essential essence. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 22 The Stage of Social Deconstruction Deconstruction as it relates to stages in genre development passes through four stages of existence, according to Hansen, Cottle, Megrine and Newbold’s (1998:17) cited in (Emielu, 2013). They are the experimental stage, the classical stage, parody stage and the stage of deconstruction. The experimental stage features a collection of principal elements that define its essence and symbolism. The classical stage represents point of maximum and clearest identification of the principal elements of the genre. The parody and the stage of deconstruction are stages where the generic elements and conventions call attention to themselves by being placed outside of their original contexts. Emielu (2013) explains the term ‘social deconstruction’ to mean the disruption of the principal elements, encrypted meanings, conventions and iconography instilled in a social construct. Hence, social deconstruction represents a process where the engrafted meaning, coventions, symbolism and iconography in a social construct to lose their absolute advantages as emergent social and historical forces act upon them. The stage of social deconstruction is characterised by features such as gradual deviation from the musical style’s core essence and definitive framework, gradual loss of the original meaning of its creators, and introduction of new stylistic innovations into the musical product. The Stage of Social Reconstruction A musical style that is socially constructed should have a meaningful fundamental principle that can be identified. It should also have peripheral aspects in levels of intensity which represent progressions towards deconstruction and reconstruction. This stage constitutes remarkable efforts regarding re-defining the social construct in stylistic and social terms, that are © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 23 novel. At this stage the “old” and “new” are combined in dimensions that ascribe new musical and social meanings to the product. It is a process that is in continuity because it responds to the changing social world of the genre and the larger society. It has features such as diverse styles of expression which may be at variance with the original core essence, efforts at creating a new direction and a new core essence for the product, attempts at placing the musical stream within a new socio-economic, artistic and cultural space which lead to defining the audience and the domain of the product. It also includes search for new meaning through forms of ideological transformation to reflect the shifting socio-musical structure, interactions and social negotiations. The social reconstructionism model will be used to assess the development and sustenance of Bɔbɔɔbɔ. Sustainabilty Sustainability is a very relevant term in contemporary times. According to Jeff Titon, “sustainability is directed today, at resources thought to be endangered, or on the road to extinction. ”(2009:120). Sustainability is related to other terms such as safeguarding, preservation and salvaging. Beddoe, et al. (2009), states that culture exerts influence on sustainability because it is values, norms and practices of society that will either corperate with or disregard sustainable goals. Cultural sustainability as mentioned earlier is concern with deals with the preservation of the culture such that both current and future generations can have the opportunity to access their cultural resources and to meet their cultural needs without discriminatory. (Throsby, 2008). Cultural sustainability as a concept has not been without dissenting views. While the concept is seen by some as idealistic and unattainable because culture, by its nature is dynamic and © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 24 subject to changes (Antrop, 2006), others believe there are not well-defined foundations for the study of cultural sustainability (Auclair & Fairclough, 2015). However, since music is part of culture, and also the subject of this study, a key interest has to be taken in its sustainability. A handful of Ethnomusicologist who have written on music and sustainability (see Allen & Libin, 2016; Challe, 2015; Schippers & Grant, 2016 and Titon, 2015). Titon (2009) writing on music and sustainability, notes that music is inclusive of the “… resources thought to be endangered, or on the road to extinction ... additionally, university ethnomusicologists and folklorists, independent scholars, music industry workers, and community scholars and activists intervene to help music cultures maintain and promote their music, whether considered endangered or not” (2009:120). This suggests that the music sustainability should only focus on dying music traditions but also vibrant ones. Therefore, in this study I use music sustainability not in reference to a waning music culture, but a vibrant one which is borborbor. I also embrace music sustainability to mean “the condition under which music genres can thrive, evolve and survive” (Schippers & Grant, 2016:7). I use the five-domain framework as an ecological approach to sustainability (Schippers, 2016), to understand how it influences sustainability of Bɔbɔɔbɔ. These domains are: systems of learning music, musicians and communities, contexts and constructs, regulations and infrastructure, and media and the music industry. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 25 Methodology I applied the qualitative research approach employing ethnographic participant observation and interviews in gathering primary data. Through that, I studied the activities of Bɔbɔɔbɔ ensembles and their members extensively. The field in this study context was Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances in Accra and the Volta region. I explored their organisation and performance practices. My choice of several Bɔbɔɔbɔ groups in Accra and Volta region was informed by Two main considerations. Firstly, Volta region is the home of Bɔbɔɔbɔ music and it is the geographical location where a lot of Eʋes and Bɔbɔɔbɔ ensembles are found. Secondly, Accra is a cosmopolitan area with numerous Bɔbɔɔbɔ ensembles organised by Eʋe migrants in suburbs with a substantial population of Eʋe speakers. Their presence in a cosmopolitan society with cultural, ethnic and artistic diversity provides a socio-cultural dimension which is useful for my study on innovations in Bɔbɔɔbɔ. Sampling Since my research on Bɔbɔɔbɔ music includes ensembles, composers, performers (drummers, dancers, singers), in the research field, I employed snowballing to get contacts with ensemble owners, and Bɔbɔɔbɔ practitioners. Since Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances take place in many towns and communities in the Volta region and suburbs of Accra regularly on weekends, there was no difficulty in observing performances and making appointments with groups and members. Through selective sampling method I had the liberty to choose any interviewee or participants within the groups, as patterns emerged during the collection of data. I used the purposive sampling technique in this study to purposefully select veteran Bɔbɔɔbɔ practitioners, opinion leaders, culture © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 26 bearers, famous Bɔbɔɔbɔ artists, older people who have lived memories of the performance, and who are knowledgeable in aspects of the tradition. Simple random sampling and snowballing were used to get Bɔbɔɔbɔ enthusiasts for interviews. I also used saturation and dens sampling in the selection of Bɔbɔɔbɔ songs. Apart from the people I knew who connected me to the leaders of the ensembles, building rapport with members of the ensembles for the first time did not pose any challenge for me. Most often, my entry strategy was to first of all join them in performance by singing the chorus of the songs and engaging in hand-clapping. In cases where I was not familiar with the songs, humming and following the melody of the songs provided a better option. Then, after a while, I offered to play the axatse (enmeshed rattle) or akaye (gourd rattle). In a number of instances, the percussionists, especially the bell player(s), were very reluctant to relinquish their instruments or roles when they could not guarantee my competence at playing the bell, since it served as the lifeline of the performance. After the performances I tried to informally interact briefly with some of the performers as a way of further consolidating the rapport. I sought the consent of group leaders and some event organisers to observe the performances, so that their members would be in the known that they were being observed. This was in the right direction as proper, and it opended the way for me to approach them later on for interactions when the need arose. I made them aware of my presence, whilst being as inconspicuous as possible. In my note book, I kept careful notes on all events, and interactions between the sampled participants. I also made video recordings of performances © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 27 at all research sites, to assist me achieve the accurate recall of the sequence of event, and also in analysing the data I collected. Subsequent to enhancing the relationships with members of the selected groups, I scheduled appointments of groups and individual musicians based on their convenience. By means of interviews, observation and participation in their performances. Interviews I employed Interviews to enable me follow through my lines of inquiry, and to also allow me to ask questions devoid of bias, in order to satisfy my research objectives (Yin 2003, Cohen, Manion, and Morrison, 2001). In order for my ethnographic interviews to have the character of everyday conversations, I made use of unstructured, semi-structured and open-ended interview questions. Unstructured interviews gave the opportunity for the interviewees to share their views and opinions without any interruptions from me. The semi- structured form of interview was suitable because of it makes it flexible to have guiding questions with the freedom of asking follow-up questions when necessary for further clarifications. I also relied on the semi-structured interview to validate certain claims and research findings. These steps were meticulously taken in view of Madison’s (2005) argument that, the ethnographer must use the resources, skills and privileges at his/her disposal to access information by penetrating boarders and confines in order to make known the voiceless voices and experiences of subjects whose stories are not known. I conducted two kinds of interviews: individual interviews and focused group interviews. The individual interviews were done with veterans and current practitioners of Bɔbɔɔbɔ. They include individual drum makers, drummers, © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 28 dancers, composers, singers and enthusiasts for Bɔbɔɔbɔ. Apart from the face- to-face interviews, I had telephone interviews with some individuals. The focused group interviews were held with groups of drummers, singers and dancers of Bɔbɔɔbɔ groups to get their views and opinions specific aspects of Bɔbɔɔbɔ performance. I also used the focused group interviews for data triangulations. Triangulation is the use of multiple sources of data in order to create a more complete picture and to cross-check some of the information (Creswell, 2000). The nature of Bɔbɔɔbɔ as a pan-Eʋe genre necessitated that most of the interviews held with the participants and all the song texts be conducted in the Eʋe language. Although some words and expressions were very difficult to translate verbatim into English because of the relationship between how the language is represented and conceptualised, my knowledge of the Eʋe language with the assistance of the Eʋe-English dictionary gave me the leverage to bring to light the verbalisations and notions embedded in the translations to their closest interpretations in English. This was for the convenience and helpfulness of both non-literate Eʋe speakers on the one hand, and non-Eʋe speakers and readers on the other. Audio and Visual Materials Qualitative audio and visual materials are described as information in the form of photographs, art objects, videotapes, website main pages, e-mails, text messages, social media text, or any forms of sound (Crewel, 2014) which a researcher may make use of. Audio and Video recording - With the use of a Sony Handheld HD Camcorder, a Zoom H4N Portable Digital audio recorder, and a smart-phone, I © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 29 was able to cover interviews, Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances of groups including rehearsal sessions in their various natural contexts, over a sustained period of time (Schaeffer, 1995). It was helpful in that it assisted me to put observations into their right perspectives prior to analysis. Digital Archives I also made use of video and audio documentaries. These include those that are online and offline. The online archives consist of songs, performance videos, films, interviews and pictures that provide factual report on aspects of Bɔbɔɔbɔ which I retrieved YouTube, WhatsApp and others using the internet. The offline digital audio-visual archives consist of audio files I listened to at the J.H. Kwabena Nketia Audio-visual Archives, performances stored on Bɔbɔɔbɔ CDs and DVDs which I purchased from vendors on the commercial markets in Ashaiman and Tudu in Accra, and Ho in the Volta region. Some were also given to me by the artists. These materials served as tools for transcription and allowed me to select, register, encode, and manipulate features to support my major analytical goals. Data Processing and Analysis In all one hundred and fifteen songs were textually transcribed using EXMARaLDA Partitur Editor version 1.6 software. After the songs were transcribed, I held discussions with the hadzenɔwo, and in some cases singers in the group, to double-check the right texts of the songs. To ensure its effectiveness, I read the texts of the songs aloud to them while they listened attentively and drew my attention to errors they noticed in the transcriptions. I also gave them the opportunity to give their opinions about the song texts and © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 30 the contexts within which they were composed or sung and the inferences they could draw from them regarding meanings and significance. The songs were later translated into the English language. The recorded field interviews were all thus transcribed in Eʋe and later translated into English. I organised a post-transcription discussion with some key informants who granted me extensive interviews to confirm the accuracy or otherwise of my transcriptions. While all the songs were also translated into the English language, a selected few were transcribed musically using Finale Software. After transcription of the songs, they were carefully analysed and some themes were deduced from them. Overall, one hundred and twelve songs were transcribed out of the total of the two hundred and forty-six songs collected. These songs include but not limited to folk tunes and original compositions, the orthodox Christian hymns. In order to assess the socio- cultural, political and religious significance of Bɔbɔɔbɔ texts, I employed the qualitative content analysis to interprete the song and drum texts. Scope of Study The study largely focuses on selected Bɔbɔɔbɔ ensembles and individual musicians and events in the Eʋe communities in parts of the Volta Region, and the Greater Accra Region. These geographical locations were chosen because they are hub where I found most Bɔbɔɔbɔ performance groups. The study is limited to the innovations in Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances and the question of sustainability of the genre. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 31 The Researcher and the Field Born and nurtured in Adabraka in the heart of Accra by parents who were both Anlovi akuakuawo (full blooded Anlo), I grew up participating in children’s games, funeral activities, outdooring activities, story-telling sittings and traditional dances within the community. When school was on long vacation, my siblings and I were sent to spend the three-month long vacation with our maternal grandmother at Woe in the Keta district of the Volta Region. The reason for this, I believe, was to give our parents some respite from the headache of wondering what their children may be doing in a compound-house while they were away at work. My first experience of living in a rural community without electricity, especially in the evenings, was that it was boring, at the beginning. But I soon realised, after a few days of settling into the community and making new friends and acquaintances, that it could be fun staying in the community. Since my grandmother was a member of a habɔbɔ (voluntary association), which also serves a music ensemble. I accompanied her and other elderly relatives to hakpa (singing rehearsal), ʋufofe (dance- drumming performance venue), and funeral celebrations. We also spent time during evenings when our grandmother told us tales and myths about clans and totems. After each long vacation spent in Woe, I came back to Accra with new folk songs, dance movements, tales and children’s games, some of which I taught to my peers when the opportunity presented itself. Back in Adabraka, I had the privilege of following my parents on Sundays to worship at the Evangelical Presbyterian (E.P) Church, located at the Nima estate. There I experienced Eʋe traditional dance drumming accompanied by the congregational singing of Western hymns translated into Eʋe, and hymns © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 32 composed by Eʋe musicians trained in Western harmony. At the children’s service, usually referred to as Sunday school, we learnt Bible stories and scriptural verses in the Eʋe language. Due to the Eʋe adage exegbe ye exe dona (literally, it is the bird’s language that it speaks, or the bird speaks the language of birds), the Sunday school sessions were held in the Eʋe language. There, I learned to read Eʋe. We were also introduced to other aspects of the Eʋe culture. For example, we were taught how to play Eʋe drums and dances such as Agbadza, Gota and Bɔbɔɔbɔ, which we always showcased to the members of the adult congregation on special days held annually for children, referred to as ‘children’s day celebration’. In later years, I also witnessed and participated in a number of Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances in Christian and non-Christian contexts. One such performance I witnessed was during the final funeral rites of a friend’s late father at Have, a town in the Volta region of Ghana in February 2014. This Bɔbɔɔbɔ performance was accompanied with a heavy brass band section and dancers. Perhaps the most memorable of all the performances I have witnessed, is a Bɔbɔɔbɔ competition dubbed ‘Borborfest 2010’ held in Accra. Those aforementioned social and religious involvements gave me a wealth of knowledge on the cultural values, behaviour, and norms of the Ga on the one hand, and that of the Eʋe, on the other. My familiarity with the musical tradition was one reason that generated my interest in opting for Bɔbɔɔbɔ musical culture as a research area. The second reason had to do with the new ideas that Bɔbɔɔbɔ musicians continue to introduce into their performances as a way of redefining the genre. Thirdly, there is the popularity it currently enjoys © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 33 across the length and breadth of the country among both Eʋe and non-Eʋe speakers. Being an Anlo-Eʋe, I was well aware that the Anlo dialect I speak is quite different from those of the Eʋedomeawo. Nonetheless, my association with some Eʋedomeawo for over two decades has given me some knowledge of the differences in dialect intonations and how to use the appropriate words in context. Through my networks I contacted some Bɔbɔɔbɔ ensembles and I visited a number of groups within Eʋe communities in Ashiama, Nima, Accra Newtown and Banana Inn (Togbikorpe), all suburbs of Accra, to observe their performances and start gathering data. My membership of the Evangelical Presbyterian (E.P) church, and my position as a former National General Secretary of the E.P. Students’ Union (EPSU), and as a chorister, gave me a broad network of Eʋe people who have ties with their families in their home towns in Eʋeland, and who in turn linked me with contacts who helped me to conduct this study. To help me get a broader picture of the Bɔbɔɔbɔ culture, I accompanied some of my Eʋedome friends and acquaintances to funerals, festivals and other ceremonies in their home towns, just to get a feel of Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances in different contexts in rural Eʋe communities. They also introduced me to people in the Bɔbɔɔbɔ fraternity and obtain the contacts of potential informants. I used these opportunities to interact with some members of the ensemble regarding their individual roles and the activities of the ensembles in the community. During one such funeral occasion, in Ho Dome, on 10 September 2016, I observed that while the Bɔbɔɔbɔ performance was still in progress, the trumpet © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 34 player came in with his usual interlude, after which he introduced a new song. Suddenly, some spectators engaged in unconstrained conversations among themselves, saying ha la ge (literally, the song has fallen). At another time during the same performance, I overheard some members of the audience again gossiping among themselves, saying ʋua mele totom o la (literally, the drum is not lively). Then, after the performance, I heard nu yeye aɖeke medze le ʋuʄoʄoa me o (literally, there is nothing new in the performance), atsia ɖeke nenɔ eme o (literally, there was no style in it), and Wo ne nɔ ‘Fo Senyo ʄe Bɔbɔɔbɔ sem (literally, they should be listening to Efo Senyo’s Bɔbɔɔbɔ). I had established acquaintances with a section of the spectators earlier so I intermittently cracked jokes and made funny comments, a strategy that got all those around me laughing while the performance was ongoing. They then started making references to how the same group had performed abysmally at another funeral occasion the previous week. Although I observed mourners, some of whom were non-Eʋe speaking friends from Accra dancing and enjoying the performance, the locals (at least those I heard murmuring and grumbling) were not impressed with the performance, hence they did not participate in the performance as one would have expected of them. In my conversations with some of the people who expressed disdain to the group’s performance, it came to light that the ensemble was a community ensemble, but they were hardly able to meet for rehearsals due to leadership problems, in-fighting within the group and factionalism in the larger community. While some attributed the lack of rehearsals and disunity in the group as the cause for the ensemble’s appalling performance, some ensemble members blamed the exodus of their best drummers, singers and trumpeter to © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 35 urban centres either to seek greener pastures or to embark on skills training programmes. I also learnt that other members have had to further their education in institutions located very far away from the community. Some of the group members admitted they only come together to perform when invited, because as a community ensemble they have an obligation to respond positively when called upon to perform during community occasions. Whatever the case, through that performance it became evident first of all that some of the informed audience or spectators have in their mind certain standards, skills and conventions they expect from performers of Bɔbɔɔbɔ. Secondly, the emphasis on the need for rehearsals and group solidarity is very significant in contributing to a successful performance. Third, the comparisons can be made between the performance we witnessed and Efo Senyo’s Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances that have been commercially recorded and disseminated through Compact Discs (CD), Digital Video Discs (DVD), MP3 files from both electronic and social media outlets. Fourth, the expectation or anticipation of spectators to see ‘something new’ in the performances put more demand on the players to bring their skilfulness and creativity to bear in order to satisfy those expectations. The experience I had on the field, and the initial secondary data I assessed from the archive and libraries gave me enough reason to adjust the focus of my work, which was initially entitled ‘Performance Practices of Bɔbɔɔbɔ Ensembles in Ashiaman’ to the broader questions of changes in Bɔbɔɔbɔ through the lenses of creativity and innovations. This made me prepare additional questions to elicit individuals’ creative abilities and the process through which they are realised. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 36 Having experienced performances in both Christian and non-Christian contexts by numerous ensembles in parts of the Volta and the Greater Accra regions of Ghana, I can attest to the fact that Bɔbɔɔbɔ bands are mixed groups with mostly men playing the drums, composing the songs and serving as cantors in performances. The standard performance structure is a circular anti-clockwise movement, as Lareau (2002), Younge (2011), Gbolonyo (2009) and Gallo (2015) have documented. Contrary to the performance structure as generalised and documented by the authors referenced, my field experiences revealed a varying performance structure which is dependent on the context of performance and the available space. Besides, new performance elements have been incorporated into the Bɔbɔɔbɔ performances, a reason that makes the study of innovaations in Bɔbɔɔbɔ of the Eʋe a plausible one in Eʋeland, Accra, and beyond. Challenges in the Field During data collection or fieldwork, I was eager to meet at least one veteran musician to discuss the history and political dimensions of the genre. At last, one Wisdom Ziiziga, a drumming instructor at the Dance Studies Department in the School of Performing Arts, University of Ghana, mentioned in a conversation a Torgbi Geofrey Kwashie Amugui, whom I later got to know as a veteran composer of Bɔbɔɔbɔ songs in the 1960s and 70s, and also as the first person to form a Bɔbɔɔbɔ band in Ho. Because I was eager to speak to this veteran Bɔbɔɔbɔ musician, I traced his where about to Golokuate in the Volta region for two days using his nickname ‘Agbaŋɔŋɔ’ (literally, perforated plate/bowl), until I finally located his residence in Ho -Dome. After introducing myself and mission, I soon found out from his son that due to health reasons and © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 37 other issues related to old age, the over 80-year old musician was not in a good state to grant me an interview. I was redirected to other elderly people in the community such as Koku Korkor, a veteran carpenter, ensemble leader and opinion leader for an interaction. As I anticipated, in a few cases there were disappointments as inteviewees did not show up for scheduled interviews. Thus, the challenges in the field were practical, concrete and at times, unfortunate. Ethical Issues For this research, it was highly important to employ a high-level of ethics in the areas of confidentiality, trust and anonymity. Hence, I ensured partial and total anonymity and confidentiality of my interviewees and participants. Although a good number them gave their consent to be mentioned, a few wished to be anonymous. For those participants who pleaded for anonymity, I depended on the requirement of informed consent as set out in McFee, (2005) and Welsh, (1999). The consent of individuals and groups were sought before audio and video recordings of interviews and performances were made. Relevant information concerning the research work was made known to the interviewees and leaders of the groups and participants I interacted with. Relevant information such as the purpose and intensions behind the research were explained to them with the opportunity to ask questions for further clarification. I assured them that there was no risk whatsoever in being interviewed in this research work the results of which will be used for academic publications, conference presentations and teaching purposes. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 38 Reflexivity It is important that researchers reflect about their own biases and backgrounds because theses dynamics shape their interpretations formed in the course of the study (Creswell, 2014). Since I have had my own experiences with Bɔbɔɔbɔ in the past, some of which will be seen later in this chapter, it is natural that a number of prejudices and notions may have unintentionally got into my data interpretation. As a consequence, I may have had a bit of bias and subjectivity that is beyond my control. Organisation of the Study The study is organised into seven chapters. Chapter One deals with the general introduction to the study. It includes the background to the study, statement of the problem, objectives, and the significance of the study, theoretical framework, methodology and literature review. Chapter Two offers a socio-cultural history of the Eʋe people of Ghana, tracing their migration, socio-political and religious structure. It also deals with the geographical locations and music and dance traditions, exploring the context for the emergence of Bɔbɔɔbɔ. Chapter Three discusses the origin and development of Bɔbɔɔbɔ, focusing on its precursors: Konkoma, Tuidzi and Akpese. It also presents historical accounts of the Bɔbɔɔbɔ genre, drawing connections to its nationalist, socio-political and religious aspects. Chapter Four explores the performance practices in Bɔbɔɔbɔ, highlighting the creativity in the musical and choreographic dimensions. The focus is on three exponents of Bɔbɔɔbɔ whose works have become the standards for Bɔbɔɔbɔ groups in Ghana. Chapter Five focuses on changing themes in Bɔbɔɔbɔ songs and their relevance to the socio-cultural, political and religious © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 39 lives of the people. Chapter Six discusses issues of sustainability in Bɔbɔɔbɔ performance, with a focus on factors that have contributed to its sustenance over the years. Chapter Seven reflects on the findings, and provides a summary and conclusion. It also offers recommendations for future research. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 40 CHAPTER TWO POLITICAL AND SOCIO-CULTURAL HISTORY OF THE EƲE OF GHANA Introduction This chapter introduces the Eʋe generally, with a special focus on the Eʋe-speaking people in Ghana. The aim of this chapter is to establish who the Eʋe in Ghana are, by tracing the trajectory of their migration, and discussing their socio-political and religious structure. It also deals with aspects of their language, occupations, and music and dance traditions. Information in this chapter is heavily dependent on works of authors such as Amenumey, (1997); Bourret (1960), Gavua, (2000), and Gbolonyo (2009). Origins and Migrations Currently, the Eʋe-speaking people of West Africa inhabit the areas from the River Volta through south-eastern Ghana (formerly the Gold Coast and British Togoland), across Togo to the River Mono on the western borders of the Ancient Kingdom of Dahomey (present-day Benin) (Nukunya,1997:8). As a larger linguistic group whose smaller groups are defined by variations in dialect and custom, the Eʋes have a common historical lineage (Agawu, 1995). As is the case with most ethnic groups in present-day Ghana, the Eʋe settled in their present homes a few centuries ago. The expansion of the Yoruba people in Ketu compelled the Eʋe to be pushed westward. Their migration from Ketu resulted in the Eʋe splitting into two major groups, with one moving southward. This group was further divided into two with one sub-group settling near the river Mono and calling it Tado. The second sub-group also settled © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 41 between the Haho and Mono rivers, which they called Notsie (Amenumey, 1997:14). The second group proceeded to the Adele region in present-day Togo. This group, which comprises the people who came to be known as the Anlo, Be, and Fon (together known as Dogboawo), later joined their relations in Notsie. There came a time in Notsie when they were ruled by King Agokoli who was said to be very wicked and harsh to his subjects. Various sections of the population decided to escape because they could not bear the tyranny of the king; hence they dispersed to inhabit the territory between the river Mono and Volta. The migration from Notsie saw the people split further into three broad groups. One of these went to settle in the northern part of their new home. The second group settled in the middle part of their new home, while the third group moved together southwards along the coast. Figure 2: Map showing the historical migration of the Eʋe Source: Cartography, Remote Sensing and GIS unit, Department of Geography and Regional Planning, UCC (2019). © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 42 The German protectorate of Togoland, which was established in 1884, enabled the Germans to control a large portion of Eʋeland which was then referred to as Togoland. The Heligoland-Zanzibar Treaty of 1890 facilitated the exchange of some African territories among Britain and Germany. It also agreed on border demarcations among the newly annexed German Togoland and British Gold Coast. The German colonial authorities were concerned with reducing reliance on imported American produce such as cotton. Therefore, they aimed to capitalize on the agricultural resources of northern part of Togoland, without due regard for the implications those actions may have on the ethnic unity of the region. It was only after two decades that the German authorities came to admit the magnitude of political and ethnic divisions imposed by the Anglo-German boundaries. It was not until 1908 that the German colonial authorities gave limited control with no genuine purpose of eventual sovereignty, to native chiefs and institutions (Bourret, 1960). The United Nations granted Great Britain and France trusteeships over their respective territories in order to facilitate and promote the eventual autonomy of the territories. During World War I (1914-1918), forces from allied colonies of British Gold Coast and French Dahomey invaded German Togoland and defeated the German Army, after which the colony was fully surrendered to the allied conquerors. In 1916, Togoland was again temporarily divided, granting territorial mandates to both Great Britain and France (Bourret, 1960), although there was uncertainty in the long-term plan for the territory’s governance (Gallo, 2015). © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 43 In response to the request from chiefs from northern Togoland, steps were taken on behalf of the French to demarcate their Togolese boundary for the purpose of the reunification of northern kingdoms such as Dagomba, Nanumba, and Mamprusi, which were separated by the Anglo-German boundary. The process of reuniting some of the northern groups resulted in the French receiving the larger portion of eastern Togoland. The new boundary which was hitherto meant to improve and sustain cohesion among ethnic groups in the north, instead created division among the Eʋe who were under British rule as part of the Gold Coast Colony in the south (Bourret, 1960). While Togoland experienced some amount of economic development during World War II, it also saw the Eʋe leaders intensifying the Eʋe unification agenda. The Vichy Government shut down the border between French and British Togoland. This boundary provoked anger against the colonial administration. In February 1946, the Eʋe Unification Movement held a convention in Accra where French Eʋe organisations were well represented. This led to a meeting of an All-Eʋe Conference in June the same year, where permanent working committees were set up to unite the Eʋes of French-Anglo Togoland in an independent administrative unit. In a monthly newspaper The Eʋes News, was published by Daniel Ahmling Chapman, an Eʋe of British Togoland, he encouraged his Eʋe comrades to work together across inter-tribal boundaries towards unification and self-government. The issue, which initially took the character of geopolitics, was later expanded into a matter of pan-Eʋe solidarity (Bourret, 1960). After a decade of campaigning which resulted in the presentation of 800 petitions to the United Nations, a 25-member delegation was sent to represent the Eʋe in New York. After numerous hearings, the United Nations Trusteeship © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 44 Council was established based on its 1945 Charter. In January 1946, Britain and France placed their mandates under the trusteeship system, which resulted in the establishment of a number of political parties, with differing ideologies regarding unification. These ideologies were influenced by historical and cultural factors. The Trusteeship Council Mission which was to ensure that colonial mandates would become trust territories, was sent to investigate matters in 1949 and 1952. The Trusteeship Council Mission made their first visit to Togoland in 1949 during which they discovered that unification would give rise to social and economic challenges, and remarked as follows: Any appraisal of the political development of Togoland under British administration must depend to a considerable degree on the solution of the problems raised by the demands for unification of the two Togolands. The Territory under British administration is small in size and population... and it is difficult to contemplate its future political and economic development except in association either with Togoland under French administration or with the neighbouring Gold Coast Colony and protectorate or possibly both {U.N. Trusteeship Council, Report of the First Visiting Mission to the Trust Territory of Togoland under British Administration, U.N. Doc. T/465 (February 1950), 19 (as cited in Bourret, Ghana: The Road to Independence, 112–3}. The Joint Council that was established in 1951 to help mediate the transfer of people and goods across British and French Togoland, was resented by many of the Eʋe groups fighting for unification. They accused the Council of ineffectiveness, inefficiency and purposeless and hence refused to cooperate with it. They later formed the Togoland Congress in the same year to continue © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 45 the campaign for the unification of the Eʋe people in the two colonial territories (Mwakikagile, 2017). Eventually, British Togoland became an administrative district of the Gold Coast in 1952 and was known as Trans-Volta-Togoland. Prior to the independence of the Gold Coast, the constitutional mandate required a significant increase in native representation and reduction in British administration. Based on that, it was the intention of the British government to separate itself from the Togoland trusteeship once the Gold Coast had become independent. In December 1955, a decision was taken to the effect that a plebiscite would be held to resolve the thorny issue of whether or not Trans- Volta-Togoland would become integrated with the Gold Coast or remain as a politically independent territory. Bourret (1960) notes that it was Osagyefo Dr. Kwame Nkrumah’s “dynamic programme” under the auspices of his Convention People’s Party (CPP) that spurred Eʋe support for the integration of Togoland with Gold Coast. On the contrary, “the rallying cry for the Eʋe who wanted unification was ablode, ablode gbadzaa (freedom, real freedom) and they became known in the rest of the Gold Coast as ablodefuo” (Amenyo, 2008). The plebiscite was to be held on 9th May 1956 under the supervision of the UN. It was such a chaotic affair, as it did not consider the wishes of the Eʋe Unification Movement, which had reached fever pitch in southern Eʋeland from Anlo to Peki, already part of the Gold Coast, and which was prevented from taking part in the plebiscite. At the end of the plebiscite, a majority made up of 93,365 people representing 58 percent in British Togoland voted for unification with the Gold Coast while a significant minority of 67,422 people representing 42 percent voted against such unification. They were not successful with the © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 46 plebiscite because of the presence of members of other ethnic groups living in the region. The non-Eʋe including some Eʋe voted to be a part of the Gold Coast (Ghana) (Mwakikagile, 2017). Had those in southern Eʋeland been given the opportunity to partake in the plebiscite, votes would have been enough to secede from the Gold Coast, as a majority voted in the Eʋe areas of the TVT to secede (Kwawukume, 2013). The advocacy continued with incipient Eʋe revolts on the eve of Ghana’s independence, as the Eʋe Unification Movement launched an armed insurrection with the use of locally made shotguns and employed guerrilla tactics in readiness to fight for their cause (Mwakikagile, 2017). But these movements were suppressed by the use of troops (Botwe-Asamoah, 2005). Currently, in Ghana, Eʋeland is bounded in the south by the Atlantic Coast, in the north by the Buem-Krachi districts of the Volta Region and in the west by the Volta river and lake (see Agbodeka, 2000). The Eʋeawo (Eʋe) in Ghana can be categorised into two broad groups, namely, the Anlo (Southern Eʋes) and Eʋedome (Northern Eʋes). The Southern Eʋe reside at the south- eastern part in the Anlo, Ketu and Akatsi districts and in the North and South Tongu districts (Amenumey, 1997). The Northern Eʋe reside at the northern parts of the Southern Eʋe in the Ho, Hohoe and Kpando districts (Gavua, 2000). They occupy a total of 4900.4 square kilometres land, representing 20% of the region’s total land size (Gockel, 2000). While the 2010 National Population and Housing Census Report estimates that the Eʋe is the third largest ethnic group in Ghana comprising 13.9% of the entire population of Ghana (Ghana statistical service 2013), the Eʋedomeawo are the second largest ethnic group of the Eʋe in Ghana, after the Anlo in the south. © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 47 Previously the Anlo established communities along the uniform, white, sandy shores of the Atlantic coast. The Eʋedome also built communities inland, north of Anlo, spreading from current Togo and Ghana, and directly westwards to the eastern shores of the Volta River and Akwapem range. The Eʋe settlements had names, some of which reflect the nature and splendour of the scenery that eventually became their home: Keta (literally, the head of the sand); Denu (literally, the beginning of palm trees); Kedzi (literally, top of the sand); Kpeve (literally, rock/stone forest); Kpedze (literally, red stone/rock); Nyive (literally, cow forest); Tsito (literally, rain mountain); Have (literally, pig forest); Todome (literally, between hills/mountain), and Adidome (literally, in/among baobab trees). Other names, such as Dzodze (literally, flew and landed) and Agbogbome (literally, in the spirit world), reflect the essence of Eʋe spiritual power (Fiagbedzi, 1977; Locke, 1978). Still others, that mirror the length of their migration and their ability to endure the hardships that came with it, include Penyi/Feyi (literally, many years past), Blamezado (literally, deceived till night falls), Dzita and Dzido (literally, top of the heart and ability to endure) (Akyeampong, 2001; Nukunya, 1997). Natural Resources and Economic Activities Eʋeland happens to be the only region that covers all climatic and vegetational belts from the coastal part to the northern part of Ghana. The southern part (coastal area) is generally low lying and undulating. The area has natural water bodies such as lagoons which include Ano (Angaw), Avu, and Keta, which are the largest of them all; marshes and salt flats, creeks, sandbars, and floodplains of the Volta river. The three lagoons are interconnected and are linked with the Volta River. It is instructive to note that a substantial part of the © University of Cape Coast https://erl.ucc.edu.gh/jspui Digitized by Sam Jonah Library 48 coastal Eʋeland in Ghana experiences erratic sea erosion which is a result of the coastline around Keta resting on a land that is below sea level. Some, however, suggest the sea erosion may be caused by a mixture of factors which include the geomorphology, hydrography, coastal subsidence, and angle of incident waves (Kufogbe, 1997). Nonetheless, the coastal area is a heavily populated area of Eʋeland (Mwakikagile, 2017; Agbodeka, 1997; Akyeampong, 2001; Armah & Amlalo, 1997). Major towns and communities located in the coastal area include Anyanyui, Anloga, Tegbi, Keta, Horvi, Denu and Aflao. The natural resources of the area such as sea, lagoons and sparse plots of sandy land around them provide the essential conditions for rather complex money-making activities such as fishing, salt mining, and trading (Gbolonyo, 2006). Nukunya (1997) succinctly states that in the coastal area “land is not only scarce but the soil is poor and climatic conditions hazardous. Thus, it is for fishing and